Loudersoft
Subscribe by RSS
  • home
  • Contact
  • browse ↓
  • Best of Lists (3)
  • Contests (16)
  • Events (20)
  • Fashion (16)
  • Festivals (65)
  • In Memoriam (1)
  • Interviews (4)
  • Letters From The Publisher (4)
  • Loudersoft Management (1)
  • Loudersoft Presents (5)
  • Memphis Music News (48)
  • Music Conferences (27)
  • Music News (358)
  • Music Videos (111)
  • Musique Non Stop (1,014)
  • New Releases (5)
  • News (5)
  • On Fire (29)
  • On Tour (16)
  • Record Store Day (2)
  • Record Store Day 2013 (2)
  • Reissues (1)

Musique Non Stop

Loudersoft Says @#$% Weezer | Chicago Pop-Punk Legends Smoking Popes Are Back And Better Than Ever

09.28.08 | 8 Comments | Posted by E.J. Friedman

Smoking Popes

(Ed. Note: I’m reposting this with updated information, so if it looks like you’ve read this, you have — but now you can go buy the record)

I’m so sick and tired of all the bullshit, aren’t you?

I am so tired of being force-fed the idea that clowning on a style that you used to do is supposed to be clever and cool. Weezer’s completely over-hyped and under-delivering 2008 release, aka the Red Album, is getting one mention in this column and one only: every time you see another article hyping Weezer, remember that there’s a conspiracy out there of people trying to steal a piece of your soul. With all due deference to Weezer (a band whom I have loved and admired for many years), the new record just didn’t cut it, boys. I know that next great Weezer record will be here someday.

But today is not your day.

Meanwhile, only through some modern miracle did the byline of a reformed Smoking Popes happen my way this morning along with a copy of their new album, entitled Stay Down. Now, you know something? I have always liked Smoking Popes & I’ve always felt like they were treated like redheaded stepchildren to Rivers & Co., turning out a series of records and touring incessantly, putting on energetic live shows that were consistent. Smoking Popes have finally made the jump to legendary status, and you should sit up and take notice. More after the jump.

Smoking Popes – Welcome to Janesville

The core of the band is a family affair, one that consists of brothers Eli, Josh and Matt Caterer. The brothers decision to split the band in 1997 (and brother Josh’s subsequent conversion to Christianity) threatened to be the end of what was, and is, an incredibly influential part of the 1990’s pop-punk movement. However, after a few additional reawakenings and off-shoots, the band reformed to little fanfare in 2006 and began touring and playing a series of Josh’s new songs. In April, Neil Hennessy from The Lawrence Arms joined them on drums. That pretty much brings you up to now.

What I can tell you about their new album, Stay Down is more than just the masterpiece of power pop that I want it to be. It’s an album filled with well-written songs, unshy about its influences and proud of them. It makes it hard, after listening to this album a few times, to put on records by those with lesser talents or vocal mastery than the brothers Caterer.

I feel strongly that this is one of those albums that people should be calling “the album of the summer 2008” because, unlike the red-headed step child that a certain other band gave birth to, Stay Down comes across as what it’s meant to be: a truly inspired and long overdue piece of work.

It’s signature pop-punk blended with these gorgeous Sinatra-influenced three-part harmonies that Smoking Popes have always been known for. But unlike some of their earlier recordings, I really hear Josh’s voice in full clarity. What sets Stay Down apart from previous Smoking Popes albums (as I remember them) is the overwhelming consistency of the quality here. The time signatures and guitar work, the songwriting and the performances really highlight how soul bankrupt other recently-released pop-punk albums are.

Do yourself a favor, Weezer fans. I’m a Weezer fan, too, ok? I find it a crime against nature that Weezer is allowed to do an album that is just average & have it praised to the high heavens while, just days before it’s released, I can’t find a single piece of press about this unbelievable new Smoking Popes release. Stay Down is so good, it might make you forget about…..uh…what was that band called?

Furthermore, I want to apologize to the Caterer brothers for going on and on, throwing up the comparison between the two records; however, in my own defense, I feel like it’s the only way I can get anyone to blow the smoke out of their eyes, to find this needle in the haystack of the internet and pay attention to the incredible album you’ve created.

Now that I’ve drawn you the best picture I can, I’m going to give you a sneak peek at one of the tracks from this album. As soon as I can tell you where to buy it, I’m going to do it right away. If you love pop-punk, indie pop or anything of the like, you would be doing yourself a favor to find Stay Down somewhere and buy it immediately. This album is waiting, needing to be heard so badly.

Smoking Popes – If You Don’t Care

I guess you can visit Smoking Popes on their MySpace page for updates until I find out what’s going on.

UPDATE: I guess this is available from iTunes by clicking here — NOW GO GET IT Smoking Popes - Stay Down

  • « Older: INTERVIEW: Aimee Mann at Bonnaroo 2008
  • » Newer: Bob Dylan’s ‘Tell Tale Signs’ to be streamed in its entirety by NPR

recent posts

  • Bobby Nourmand – Prisoner
  • Hænrik – If This Ain’t Love
  • Livia Blanc – Chocolat, Café, Passion
  • KWADI – Wrong Side of my Head
  • Gareth Inkster – Last Year
  • Topaz – Cross
  • Reggie – Forget 2 Fall

By visiting any portion of this website at any time using any means, you are agreeing to our terms of use and privacy agreement.

  • Our Editorial Team



  • Fiends and Framily

    • Nialler9
    • Pigeons and Planes
    • Pretty Much Amazing
    • Some Kind Of Awesome
    • The Music Ninja
    • We All Want Someone To Shout For
  • A-Listers

    • 20jazzfunkgreats
    • Buzzgrinder
    • Chromewaves
    • DISCODUST
    • EARMILK
    • Frolab
    • Funky 16 Corners
    • goldenfiddle
    • IHEARTCOMIX!
    • Indie Shuffle
    • La Blogotheque
    • My Old Kentucky Blog
    • Soul-Sides
    • The Vinyl District
    • We Listen For You.
  • Part Of The “Not Now But Right Now” Network

    Follow @loudersoft

  • Browse the Archives.

  • Subscribe to Loudersoft Updates via Email

    Enter your email address to subscribe to Loudersoft & you will receive an email notifying you when new content is added.

  • Best of the Web

    • Aquarium Drunkard
    • Brooklyn Vegan
    • Complex Mag
    • Consequence of Sound
    • Genius
    • Gorilla vs. Bear
    • Largehearted Boy
    • Pitchfork Media
    • Spin
    • Stereogum
    • The FADER
    • Wax Poetics
  • Internet Radio.

    • Dash Radio
    • KCRW
    • KEXP
    • RBMA Radio
    • soma fm
    • WEVL
  • Internets And Forums.

    • Goner Records
    • Okay Player
  • Creative Commons

    Commercial Use or Redistribution of Loudersoft's Original Content Is Strictly Prohibited.

    You may hotlink to images or soundfiles!*

    Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution - Noncommercial - No Derivative Works 3.0 License

    *if you don't mind us replacing the images or sound files you've hotlinked (without any notice at any time) with audio or photo content so disgusting that it will offend you, your readers and even us. You were warned. so don't hotlink.

Copyright © 2005-2018 Loudersoft. All rights reserved. | About | Privacy / Terms of Use | Advertising | Staff | Contact | RSS Feed

Follow Loudersoft on: Twitter | Facebook | Tumblr | Hype Machine | YouTube | Instagram | Etsy

Back to Top ↑